Posted by Kerrieanne
Quick answer
Our easiest handmade gifts under $25 are Goat Milk Soap ($8), Lip Balm ($5), an alcohol-free Rollerball perfume ($15) and Whipped Tallow ($20). Pair a soap, soap tray and lip balm for a $20 gift.
A good gift doesn't have to cost much. It has to feel thought-through. Handmade skincare does that: it's useful, it gets used up (so it never becomes clutter), and it comes from a real person instead of a warehouse. Almost everything below is handmade in small batches in Wisconsin, and every gift is $25 or less. Most are under $15.
Short on time? Our three easiest gifts
Goat Milk Soap ($8): our bestselling bar, in a dozen scents.
Rollerball perfume ($15): an alcohol-free perfume oil that fits in a stocking.
Whipped Tallow ($20): our richest moisturizer, whipped fresh to order.
Or browse everything in our Skincare Gifts collection.
Gifts $10 and under
Perfect for stockings, coworkers, teachers and gift swaps.
Lip Balm ($5): beeswax, shea butter and cocoa butter in Mint Vanilla or Lavender Vanilla. The easiest stocking stuffer there is.
Linen Spray ($5): lavender and lemongrass essential oils for pillows and sheets.
Lip Serum ($7): a small luxury for the person who always has something in their pocket.
Soap Tray ($7): red alder hardwood. Pair it with a bar of soap and you have a $15 gift.
Goat Milk Soap ($8): 5 oz bars made with shea butter and goat milk. Pumpkin Pie, Lavender, Cedar Saffron and Lemon Lift are all in stock.
Specialty bars ($8): Tipsy Goat Soap, made with Wisconsin beer (a fun one for beer lovers), Toasted Oatmeal, Turmeric and Charcoal Facial Soap.
Miracle Glow Balm ($10) and Under Eye Balm ($10): small balms that feel like a treat.
Gifts $15 and under
Magnesium Oil ($12): a 2 oz spray-on magnesium oil, a favorite after the shower.
Hair Perfume Mist ($12): a light scent for hair.
Neroli Grapefruit Face Toner Mist ($12): a fresh, citrusy face mist.
African Net Sponge ($14): handmade in the Netherlands in the West African style. Long, stretchy and quick-drying, in bright colors. A fun gift for anyone who still uses a loofah.
Skin Glow Facial Serum ($14).
Rollerball ($15): 10 mL of alcohol-free perfume oil in a roll-on. Unisex scents include Eclipse, Cashmere, Nordic, Sandbar and Sugar Rush. Read why we make perfume oil instead of spray perfume.
Cuticle Oil ($15): for the friend who's always working with their hands.
Solid Lotion Bar ($15): beeswax, shea and mango butter in a mess-free bar for dry hands, elbows and heels.
Gifts under $25
Whipped Sugar Scrub ($18): in Pink Paloma or Cabin Fever.
Open Water Bath Oil ($18): for the bath lover on your list.
Whipped Tallow ($20): rich, fluffy and whipped fresh to order, unscented or scented. Order a few days early.
Facial Oil ($20) and Night Facial Oil ($20): for anyone who loves a face routine.
Dream Cream ($22): a rich body butter with shea and cocoa butter.
Body Oil ($24) and Bakuchiol Facial Oil ($24).
Build your own gift for $25 or less
Two or three small things in a bag feel like more than one bigger item. A few combinations we like:
The soap lover ($20): Goat Milk Soap + Soap Tray + Lip Balm.
The shower upgrade ($22): Goat Milk Soap + African Net Sponge.
Winter hands ($20): Cuticle Oil + Lip Balm.
The beer fan ($15): Tipsy Goat Soap + Soap Tray.
A little self-care ($20): Miracle Glow Balm + Under Eye Balm.
Add our Ollie gift bag ($10) and it's ready to hand over.
Want to spend a little more?
Our ready-made gift sets come packed in a custom Ollie gift bag:
The Soap Lover Gift Set: from $32 (a $45 value). Two soaps, a soap tray, a lip balm and an add-on.
Winter Skin Rescue Gift Set: $54 (a $70 value).
The Glow Ritual Gift Set: from $60 (a $77 value). A full face routine.
Not sure what they'd like? An Ollie gift card starts at $10. You'll find more ideas in our Holiday Gift Guide.
Gift-shopping questions
Do you offer free shipping?
Yes, free economy shipping on orders of $50 or more. Several small gifts add up fast, so it's an easy way to check off a few people at once. Shipping cutoffs for the holidays are listed on every product page.
Can I pick up locally?
Yes. Choose free local pickup at checkout, or find us at a holiday market near you on our Where to Find Us page.
What's a safe gift if I don't know their skin?
Lip balm, a soap tray, a net sponge or an unscented soap are safe bets. Scented products are best for people whose scent taste you know.
Is there a discount?
Sign up for our emails and get 15% off your first order.
Gifting to someone with very sensitive skin? Suggest they patch-test anything new first.
