Posted by Kerrieanne Lischka
Quick answer
Ollie Skincare handmade goat milk soap is sold year-round in Milwaukee at All Aglow (Bay View) and MJ's Apothecary & Gifts (East Side), nearby at Farmer's Market TO GO in Brookfield and Grafton Collective, and at Milwaukee-area holiday markets through December. You can also order online with free local pickup in Richfield.
Updated November 2026 · By Kerrieanne Lischka, founder and soapmaker at Ollie Skincare
The short answer
You can buy Ollie Skincare handmade goat milk soap in Milwaukee at All Aglow in Bay View and MJ's Apothecary & Gifts on the East Side, nearby at Farmer's Market TO GO in Brookfield and Grafton Collective in Grafton, and in person at our holiday markets around the Milwaukee area through December. Or order online: free shipping on orders of $50 or more, plus free local pickup in Richfield.
We make every bar by hand in small batches in Richfield, Wisconsin, about 30 minutes northwest of downtown Milwaukee, so the soap you find in these shops is local in every sense.
Shops in and near Milwaukee
All four shops carry Ollie year-round. Selection changes from shop to shop, so if you're after a specific scent, call ahead or send me a note and I'll tell you where to find it.
All Aglow (Bay View, Milwaukee)
1800 E Howard Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207. A self-care shop with yoga gear, recovery aids and relaxation products. allaglowmke.com
MJ's Apothecary & Gifts (East Side, Milwaukee)
2008 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202. Handcrafted skincare, candles and gifts. mjs-apothecary-gifts.com
Farmer's Market TO GO (Brookfield)
17000 W Capitol Dr, Suite 2, Brookfield, WI 53005, at Capitol and Calhoun. A year-round indoor farmers market and grocery with 50+ Wisconsin farmers and makers. farmersmarket2gowisconsin.com
Grafton Collective (Grafton)
1110 Bridge St, Grafton, WI 53024. More than 50 local vendors under one roof, plus hands-on craft workshops. graftoncollectivemarketplace.com
Farther out, you'll also find us at Colby's Premium Thrift in Mukwonago and at Loveland Refillery and Schmidt Century Farm in West Bend. The full list, with a map, is on our Where to Find Us page.
Holiday markets near Milwaukee, November–December 2026
Markets are the best way to smell every scent and ask me anything in person. Here's where our table will be:
- Thu, Nov 12, 4–8:30 PM: Whitefish Bay Band Market, Whitefish Bay Middle School, Whitefish Bay
- Sat–Sun, Nov 14–15: SoLu Christmas Market at Reindeer Village, SoLu Estate, W8269 County Rd F, Cascade (Sat 10 AM–6 PM, Sun 10 AM–4 PM)
- Sun, Nov 15: The Brickyard Holiday Craft Fair, Bavarian Bierhaus, 700 W Lexington Blvd, Glendale
- Sat, Nov 21, 9 AM–3 PM: Holiday Craft Fair of Washington County, Washington County Fair Park, 3000 Hwy PV, West Bend ($5 admission, ages 12 and up)
- Sat, Nov 28, 9 AM–1 PM: Port Washington Winter Market, Edison Hall at Inventors Brewpub, 305 E Washington St, Port Washington
- Thu, Dec 3, 5–8 PM: Port Washington Winter Market, Edison Hall at Inventors Brewpub, Port Washington
- Fri–Sat, Dec 4–5, 5–10 PM: Sauced Milwaukee, Pilot Project Brewing, 1128 N 9th St, Milwaukee (free with RSVP, all ages)
- Sat, Dec 12, 9 AM–1 PM: Port Washington Winter Market, Edison Hall at Inventors Brewpub, Port Washington
- Sun, Dec 13, 10 AM–4 PM: The Makers Club Holiday Market, 415 N Genesee St, Delafield (free admission)
- Sat, Dec 19, 9 AM–1 PM: Port Washington Winter Market, Edison Hall at Inventors Brewpub, Port Washington
Order ahead, pick up from your car: most Thursdays from 5–6 PM, we're part of the Local Dash drive-thru winter market at the Sippie Hippie parking lot, 319 E Washington St, Slinger. Order and pay in the Local Dash Facebook group by Tuesday night.
Dates can change with weather and organizers, so check Where to Find Us for the latest before you head out.
Order online, ship or pick up in Richfield
Can't make a market? Everything is on our website, and orders ship within 2–3 business days. Shipping is free on orders of $50 or more, or choose free local pickup in Richfield at checkout.
What to try first
- Goat Milk Soap ($8): our everyday bar in many scents, made with goat milk from a farm in Clintonville, Wisconsin. Pick Beauty Bare (Unscented) if you prefer no added scent.
- Whipped Tallow ($20): a whipped face and body butter for dry winter skin.
- Magnesium Oil ($12, 2 oz): a topical magnesium spray made with magnesium flakes, distilled water and peppermint, rosemary, camphor and clary sage essential oils. It feels cool and fresh on shoulders, neck and legs after a workout or a long day, and sinks in without residue.
- Stocking Stuffers $15 and Under, if you're shopping for gifts.
Curious what makes goat milk soap different? Read What Does Goat Milk Actually Do for Your Skin? New to magnesium spray? Read What Is Magnesium Oil?
About Ollie Skincare
Ollie Skincare is a woman-owned, small-batch skincare brand in Richfield, Wisconsin. I began making goat milk soap on our Wisconsin homestead in 2016, and we've been selling Ollie Skincare since 2018. Our products are Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free, and we're a member of 1% for the Planet. Read our story.
Common questions
Where can I buy handmade goat milk soap in Milwaukee?
At All Aglow in Bay View and MJ's Apothecary & Gifts on the East Side, at our Milwaukee-area holiday markets, or online at ollieskincare.com.
Is there a shop open year-round near Milwaukee?
Yes. All four shops above carry Ollie year-round, including Farmer's Market TO GO in Brookfield, a year-round indoor market.
Do you have a storefront?
No, we sell online, at markets and through local shops. If you're nearby, choose free local pickup in Richfield at checkout.
Can I order online and pick up?
Yes. Free local pickup in Richfield is an option at checkout, and shipping is free on orders of $50 or more.
